Rachel Carson and Unintended Consequences

Our generation is unique. The generations preceding us did not face the challenge of saving the environment, primarily because they did not know it needed saving. From the dawn of the Industrial Revolution until the mid twentieth century, most people believed that we had the capability to control nature. Even after World War II, this trend continued due to inventions including the atomic bomb, insecticides, and space travel. No one seemed to understand that man is part of nature, not above it. However, this mentality shifted after the publication of Silent Spring. The revolutionary book, penned by Rachel Carson in 1962, warned of the negative consequences of the pesticide DDT.

Rachel_Carson_w
Image Credit 

 

“It is ironic to think that man might determine his own future by something so seemingly trivial as the choice of an insect spray” (8).

Although today the use of DDT is banned in the United States and several other countries, Carson’s book is still relevant for its timeless lessons regarding the unintended consequences of advancements in technology. Unintended consequences narrate the historic relationship between humans and the environment; we are just now starting to understand that there is a price to progress that had not been anticipated. Our generation must combat climate change because earlier generations did not foresee how rapid industrialization would leave a carbon footprint on the environment.

The problem with unintended consequences is that they are unintended. This sounds obvious, but it also emphasizes an important point. How can you prevent the problems when you don’t see them coming? The answer is that you can’t. Scary, I know.

quote-there-are-downsides-to-everything-there-are-unintended-consequences-to-everything-steve-jobs-105-99-47
Image Credit 

However, just because choices we make can have negative repercussions does not mean we should not make decisions. Rather, we must be more conscious of the potential effects of our choices. Humans are part of the natural world; we not only have to deal with how we affect one another, but also how we affect other species and the environment. Rachel Carson was principally concerned with making people aware of how DDT affects more than just the targeted insects, but her notion of unintended consequences applies to more than that. In the following quote, she exemplifies that we have to first consider the importance of the interconnectedness of the world.

“The predator and the preyed upon exist not alone, but as a part of a vast web of life, all of which needs to be taken into account” (293).

It is easy to forget we are part of a larger picture, but this forgetful attitude is incredibly dangerous. Carson’s Silent Spring launched the environmental movement by calling our attention to the problems, but it is our responsibility to rethink how we interact with the natural world if we wish to endure.

Sant_Maurici_lake,_Aigüestortes_i_Estany_de_Sant_Maurici_National_Park,_Spain_-_Diliff
Image Credit 
Advertisements

3 thoughts on “Rachel Carson and Unintended Consequences

  1. Hi Sadie,

    I really enjoyed reading this entry. You brought up a good point on explaining how Rachel Carson’s text is timeless despite the fact that DDT is already banned in the US. The problem here is not simply DDT only. Rather Rachel Carson is trying to convince us to think twice before trying out any new technology in general. They might bring unintended consequences just because we have never had any prior experiences with them. In that sense, her book becomes more relevant than ever. We live in an age where science and technology are rapidly developing. Some of the innovations are so new and radical, we have no idea of what possible side effects that they might bring.

    I also like your discussion about the fact that we should still make decisions despite the unknown unknowns. This contrasts with the point of view that Kingsnorth and Hein in “The Dark Mountain” manifesto. They argued that since progress creates problems, or unintended consequences as you put it, we should stop making progress at all and revert to being uncivilized. I understand that their argument has validity; we did not have these problems back when we were primitive, then going backwards seems like a foolproof solution. However I personally believe that this mindset goes against human nature which wants to make progress. By becoming natural, they are asking humankind to go against their instincts, and that does not make sense to me. I am more inclined to think in the point of view that you offered: That we should move forward, but at the same time be very wary of the possible consequences of our advance. Man is not above nature. Never have, never will be.

    Like

  2. Pingback: References to other blogs – A Window on The World

  3. I also found your entry to be very interesting to read. I think it is extremely important for us to be cognizant of the consequences of every decision we make, especially in the world that we live in today. We have been able to witness first hand the effects that being careless with technological advancements can have on our environment, and they are not positive ones. Previous generations have left us with some seemingly irreversible damage and it is our responsibility to try to not leave that for the generations that follow us. However, I do also agree with your thought that just because of the unintended consequences that may follow the creation of new technology does not mean that we should just stop creating new technology all together. We should continue, just with caution. I think it is good that we’ve been able to see what happens when we don’t consider the long term, because then we can avoid that in the future and make sure we really do think about the effects of what we do. We are aware of the mistakes that we have made previously, and now we can do everything in our power to avoid making those mistakes again.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s